The Cost of Waging the Culture War (Part 1)

Since at least the founding of the Moral Majority in 1979 by the late Jerry Falwell, Evangelical Christianity has been involved in a culture war. Though the Moral Majority disbanded, other leaders have stepped up where it left off. Think of people like the late Dr. James Kennedy, the founding Pastor of the Coral Ridge Presbyterian Church in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, and Dr. James Dobson, founder of Focus on the Family. Growing up in a Church of Christ, I can even remember watching Sunday School videos of Rubel Shelly, a popular leader among Churches of Christ, warning about the dangers of bands like KISS and AC/DC.

Over the years as the culture war has intensified, Christians have been strongly encouraged to vote with their conscience. Concerned Christians believed that if the results of the elections could be swayed by their votes, that some semblance of Christian society could remain. One blogger has described this use of political power as “coercion by legislation”. That is to that Christianity is using politics to try and legislate Christian values upon society. But at what cost?

In a blog post I wrote a while back (you can read it here), I described the current cultural climate as a large table conversation taking place in which a variety of beliefs and value systems are having a large conversation. Christianity is only one voice at the table but it also finds itself increasingly unwelcome at the table. People have grown weary of Christians trying to always get their way. And they see through the claims of “doing God’s work” or “defending the cause of Christ” as simply a selfish act.

Now it may be that the other voices at the table are just as selfish but what gives Christians the right to be selfish? In his letter to the Philippians, the Apostle Paul insisted that Christians adopt the same attitude of Jesus who “made himself nothing by taking on the very nature of a servant… …becoming obedient to death — even death on a cross” (Phil 2:5-8). Paul was writing to a church divided over an issue between two Christian women (4:2). Yet as he wrote, he was calling the church back to the way of Jesus. The point is that even if they believe they are in the right, they must let go of their right to be right and become a servant to each other.

That is what I call cross power. Instead of employing force or coercive tactics, Christians are called to become servants even if it means being wronged and mistreated. Yet the Christianity I am part of, American Christianity, has largely forgotten this. While most Christians have not resorted to violent force, we have have been very forceful with our beliefs and values.

Yet as we fight this cultural war, the first cost of winning seems to be sacrificing our soul. That is, at the expense of fighting this cultural war with the coercive tactics of this world, we are giving up the heart of the gospel that we have been called to embody. We can proclaim that Jesus is the way, truth, and life (Jn 14.6) all we want but if we do not embody that way, truth, and life in our own ways, our proclamation is nothing more than hypocrisy.

I speak only for myself but if having a society where the laws reflect Christian beliefs and values means giving up the way of Christ, count me out. I believe in and follow Jesus, not a political movement that has hijacked the name “Christianity” for its cause.

7 responses to “The Cost of Waging the Culture War (Part 1)

  1. selfish….perhaps, or, perhaps selfless; that is a judgment of motives; I do not know the motives of their hearts; but enacting legislation that defends chidlren from sexual predators is good; and enacting legislation that prohibits teaching homosexuality to children is good; as the Good Book says, ‘train up a child in the way he should go….’; also restraining the predations of lust-driven men is good; Eli did not, and God struck him dead. Just because the unrepentant do not feel loved, does not mean we retire from the discussion. Defend the fatherless and the widows; protect the innocents.
    It is in society’s interest to define the procreating, male and female marriage as the norm, for one cannot have two norms. To defend it could be selfish or selfless. I know parents who do not teach the Christian faith to their children so that they can make an ‘objective’ choice when the grow up; but that leaves the choice to the State Schools that are fierce in their indoctrination based on the lies of Kinsey, and Margaret Mead, both of whom fabricated sexual data in order to lead us into a sexual revolution.
    Herod lopped off the head of John the Baptist because he did not feel loved by John the Baptist; it made him angry that his sin was exposed. The law is a schoolmaster to Christ and that includes the laws instituted by the government; woe to those who call good, evil; and evil, good. Government is not only to use the sword against the evil, but promote the good, so says Romans 13. No, by abandoning the public sphere and giving the dialogue only to the snake, we do no man a service; but when we speak the law in the public domain it must be done with love, and it must always be done with the declaration that only the Gospel can bring the righteousness that matters in the the lives of those who are called to live in the kingdoms of this world. But deliver me from the sin of Eli. Lord, have mercy on me a sinner.

    • Not only am I a part of this American Christianity, I think I’ve been around long enough to have a pulse on what it motivating the engagement in this culture war: fear. And fear typically drives us to worry about ourselves first. That is why I believe the primary concern is the preservation of a “Christian friendly” culture. If instead the concern was merely about preserving a culture of justice and righteousness, like God is concerned with, we might expect to our prioritization of important issues to parallel what God has given importance too (I could really write another blog post here).

  2. Very well said,”Give up the right to be right and become a servant to each other.” This is the teaching of our Lord. Amen

  3. Jason Bennett

    Great stuff!

  4. Pingback: The Cost of Waging the Culture War (Part 2) | Kingdom Seeking

  5. Pingback: this went thru my mind |

  6. Pingback: Christian Resources for Thinking About Homosexuality « Peter’s Patter

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s