Pseudo Spirituality and True Spirituality

The other day I went into Dunkin Donuts to get a cup of coffee.  The man waiting in line in front of me was Jewish.  I know this because he was wearing a kippah or yarmulke on his head.  Then there was the lady taking my coffee order.  She was a Hindu.  I know this because she had the bindi dot on her forehead.

This got me thinking some about how people define their religious or spiritual life by certain signs.  A person is somehow religious or more spiritual because of some identifiable mark they wear or carry with them in public.  The hijab head-covering that Muslim men wear or the Rosary Beads many Catholics carry with them also comes to mind.

It would be easy to become hyper-critical of such people for thinking that we’re supposed to recognize their spirituality by those identifiable marks they wear or carry with them.  But then I realize the ways in which protestant Christians, even Evangelical, and yes even in my own tribe, the Churches of Christ, can rely on such identifiable marks to say “I am spiritual” or “I am a Christian”.  It’s done…

  • Every time we judge another person by the way he or she dresses when “coming to church.”
  • Every time we judge one’s Christianity by the number church activities they participate in.
  • Every time we rely on a fish symbol affixed to our car bumper, a golden cross necklace, or the  carrying of a Bible to identify our godliness.
  • every time we insist that church leaders wear their “Sunday best” and judge their spiritual leadership by that standard.

The problem with all of this isn’t the symbols or marks themselves.  The problem is that we can have a fish symbol displayed on our car, wear a taylor-made 3 piece suit, always carry our Bible in hand wherever we go, and be present in some way at every church activity…and still be the most unspiritual, least Christ-like and Spirit-filled people in the room.

In the New Testament, real spirituality is not marked by any external marker we might use to identify our religion.  For followers of Jesus Christ, real spirituality is marked by the life we live.  It’s a life that says “no” to the desires of the flesh and yes to the life lived by the Spirit of God (cf. Gal 5.13ff).  It’s a life that puts away our old self and puts on the new self that is being created to be like God (cf. Eph 4.22-24).  It’s a life that marks us as belonging to God by clothing ourselves “with compassion, kindness, humility, gentleness, and patience.  [Bearing] with each other and [forgiving] one another…” that is ultimately bound together by love (Col 3.12-14).

That is true spirituality.  It is, I contend, much harder to do than settling for some form of pseudo spirituality even though the later seems very hip and even has the outward appearance of being right.  May God grant us the grace from his love and the strength from his Spirit to pursue true spirituality!

3 responses to “Pseudo Spirituality and True Spirituality

  1. Amen. mostly! Heart Christianity. Yes. The only qualifier I would bring to it is that because we are not gnostics, or body-denying and matter-repudiating folks of other stripes, while the inner man of the heart is the most important issue, there are forms that express our faith. When the apostle opposed those who had a form of Godliness but denied the power, he was not opposed to forms but to the denial of the power.
    There is the opposite temptation to say; Lord I do not have a rosary, and I do not wear a crucifix; my religion is inward and of the heart; I am not like those people who wear their religion on their sleeve, or the bumper sticker…. and there we have it; we have become Pharisees in the pursuit of religion of the heart.

    The coming of Christ will also be marked by an exterior sign, the sign of the Cross, and because we have bodies inner prayer will configure our bodies if we are praying with our whole heart; we may find ourselves kneeling, or standing, or bowing our heads or raising our heads; fasting, or feasting to the glory of God.

    Yes let us not judge according to outward forms. But let us not despise forms, for heart Christianity will find forms appropriate for its expression.

    …who being found in the form of a servant, humbled himself…to death on a cross (another form).

    Deliver us O Jesus to the faith that expresses itself from within our heart by the faith of Christ, in a world that can only see the outward. Lord have mercy 12x.

    • Yes, I probably did not make it clear but I am not opposed to people wearing a cross, prayer beads, etc… if that helps remind them of their calling to be Christ-like. I am just opposed to the thinking that relies on symbols to announce our spirituality to the world rather than the way we live.

      Any ways, I hope you know that even though I don’t always agree with you, I really do appreciate your comments and the insight you bring with your Eastern Orthodox perspective. That is a voice that is not heard enough among western influenced Christians.

      Grace and Peace,


  2. Hi Rex, I figured I should let you know that I am with you all the way on this one. 8<) –dc

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s